Damien Symonds

@oliveoh, please do this for me: https://www.damiensymonds.net/thread1.html

I realise it's not perfect, but it's the best I can offer, I'm afraid.

How did you go, @calliechinen?

@fstoplife, how did you go? Have you managed to find out what light setup she uses?

You'd go for the 5000, I figure. But yeah, the brightness is really important too.

It's time to take a refresher on the Raw Class. It's been a LONG time since you took it, and a LOT has changed. https://ask.damiensymonds.net/topic/8494-raw-signup-1/

?

Great, I look forward to hearing.

That's right. Again, her light is smaller, higher and brighter than yours.

I need you to take a look at the catchlights in her photos. See how they're smaller, brighter and higher than yours? She has specifically shot for this style. Whereas you have taken a lovely but "regular" photo.

My understanding is that eyes are usually enlarged slightly during this kind of editing; so I hope you don't mind that I did that, and a little bit of facial sculpting. What do you think of this?

Gosh.

I hope I don't offend anyone by saying this, but I think race is important here. Can you choose a sample photo of somebody with a similar complexion to your subject?

It's the "Download PSD" link earlier in the thread.

Examine each of the layers to see what role it plays in the outcome.

Oh my goodness. What degree of optimism is there for his rehabilitation?

How did you go?

@Melissalile, where are you?

I'm always very concerned about using lamps. Their light is so ... directional, you know? Just to check - have you read this? https://www.damiensymonds.net/2012/01/light-around-your-computer.html

Phew. As it happens, you got lucky this time, because we do need that duplicate layer. You need to apply some Gaussian Blur to it - just enough to get rid of the distinct fabric lines, eg around your hand. I think about 0.6 will do. Then mask that layer too.

Geez, you don't make a habit of this, do you? Don't double the size of your file for "no real purpose"!

There's a bit more we need to do. First, can you tell me what the "Background copy" layer is for?

May I see a screenshot of the Detail (noise) panel from ACR for this photo?

It's not black-and-white, don't you see? It's pant-colour.

If there is a problem with your pants, I don't understand why you wouldn't assume the solution would involve masking to your pants?