Damien Symonds

I'm so sorry, I don't understand the question. Can you elaborate?

Well, nothing you've shown us here presents any evidence of it.

Please also remember that this is ISO 500, compared with the other two which were ISO 800. It's not a huge difference, but it's not nothing either.

No, this is not what I'm saying at all! It's not user error, it's not even an error at all! These photos are PERFECT.

Yeah, that's way too low for any web purpose, but especially when you're seeking feedback from peers about file quality. Can you take the last three 100% crops again, and save them at Level 10 for upload?

Fantastic. But can you tell me what quality level you chose when saving those jpeg files for upload here?

Can you do this for me?

The only complicating factor is the little bit of missing wing on the right side of the big girl. I had to borrow some other bits of wing to recreate the missing areas here:

That's right. Open the first image and extend the canvas size to the left. Add more than you think you'll need. Then File>Place the second image. Then lower its opacity and fiddle with it until it lines up as best you can. Then mask.

Have you read through the Layers & Masks Class yet?

Great. So in that case, I think your best chance is to use the left side of the second photo (including the bigger girl) and the right side of the first photo (including the smaller girl) and have the blend between them.

Photoshop CC has an auto save feature, which might have helped, but I'm not optimistic. Some discussion about it here.

You explained it perfectly. I understand exactly what you want. Please answer my question. Do you mind which version of the older girl we use?

I can see why you prefer the little girl in the first photo. But is there a reason you prefer the big girl in the first photo? She looks nice in both to me.

Your file is perfect. This is a cock-up at their end.

Could you send me the PDF?

I think she'll be very pleased with that. Well done.

http://www.damiensymonds.net/2013/09/grabbing-700x700px-100-crop.html

Great question. Maybe this?

You need to make the edges a bit better.

What makes you think those Pinterest ones weren't actually drawn with chalk, and photographed?

Maybe this? http://www.damiensymonds.net/2015/08/fixing-tan-lines.html

Sorry, I mean, restart your computer then open PSE again, and take a screenshot to show me the problem.

It was never broken, I promise. That's how it has always been. It only shows when a photo is open.

Again, a screenshot please.