Damien Symonds

No, it won't band. You already read the tutorial, you linked it in your original post. DO NOT MAKE THE BACKGROUND ENTIRELY BLACK. I can't stress this enough. The baby's hair will disappear completely, and it will look ridiculous. NEVER quick selection or magic wand. And definitely never the stupid Refine Edge feature.

Download the PSD of the lighter one Download the PSD of the darker one

It probably goes without saying that the easiest option is to keep the background exactly as it already is around the hair. Masking around the rest is quite easy, using the Shift key, but it's easiest if we can avoid masking around hair at all. Here it is with the background kept the same around the hair: But I'm pleased to say it's not too difficult if you wish to make it darker, either. Just the addition of another Levels layer. Do either of those suit you?

There aren't shades of black. Black is black. Do you mean a darker grey background?

Hi Cathy, what would you like to replace the background with, exactly?

Well, gosh, I'd hope that you don't have to do it very often. This was a special case - a combination of the fake tan, and your decision to shoot her outdoors amid so much cast-throwing foliage.

No, you're a bit confused here. The monitor calibration profile isn't sRGB, or Adobe RGB, or any other standard form of RGB. It's very unique to your screen, and it'll be whatever you named it. More info here. The one you're seeing at the bottom of Photoshop is the image profile. And yes, it must be sRGB. Use this troubleshooter if it's not.

Let me know how it goes for you.

Can you see this one? http://www.damiensymonds.net/art_tscs2.html

It's looking a bit unnatural around the boy's hair.

This troubleshooter will help you decide that.

I'll need some more information. Do you mean you can't open your raw files to open them? Or do you mean you can't even get them off the card?

By using grids.

Oh gee, you must NEVER touch the Assign Profile menu item. Fix your colour space issues here.

Here's a file for you to download and see First, roughly clone the other eye across, then mask it more accurately. More information here. The other eye is a bit lighter, so the cloned area will need to be darkened a bit. So add a dodge and burn layer, and clip it (Ctrl Alt G) to the cloned layer, then burn as needed. More information here.

Well, maybe all the way back to the raw file. It depends where the clipping occurred.

You STILL can't post photos?

Terrific! Now gently apply some Cooling Filter LBB.

Yes, the troubleshooter should have guided you to this one?

To begin with, go through this.

Wonderful! Much nicer already. There's more I wish I could discuss with you about the raw processing aspect of this photo, but I can't do so here, sorry. I urge you to get on the Raw Class waiting list as soon as you can (if you haven't already). So for now, I'll have to make do as best we can. Before we get to the colouring issue, I need you to brighten the hands and the face, so that they're more of a match for her chest/shoulders area. (A match in brightness, don't worry about the colour for now. Then post again for me.

Yep, we can do this. Can you take a close crop of her face for me?

Oh, I can't wait to hear how they turn out! I'll sit here fidgetting in the meantime

Are you referring to the fact that her right eye (our left) has two catchlights in it instead of one?

Oh heck no. The white balance must be correct in raw. NEVER look at skintone in raw, period.